Intermediary asset pricing and the financial crisis uchicago voices. We argue that relative predictability of more vs less intermediated asset classes by inter. Most forms of the capital asset pricing model assume that price differences can be effortlessly arbitraged away. Krishnamurthy talks about two things from his paper coauthored with zhiguo he. Also, many of the most recent discoveries on empirical asset pricing since discount rates arent really in any textbook. Investing in risky assets is so hard that most is done via intermediaries and someone has to manage the intermediaries. In such frameworks, the leverage of nancial intermediaries measures the tightness of intermediary funding constraints and therefore their marginal value of wealth. In the last few years, the intermediary theory of asset pricing has emerged as a single factor model of asset pricing that does as well as the standard four factor model and thus subsumes the size, value and momentum factors adrian, t. Im sure intermediary asset pricing is in no textbook. This article explains the theory behind intermediary asset pricing and, in particular, how it is different from other.
Intermediary asset pricing olin business school washington. Intermediary balance sheets tobias adrian and nina. There is also duffies book, which while old, covers continuous time and dynamic asset pricing very well. We find that shocks to the equity capital ratio of financial intermediariesprimary dealer counterparties of the new york federal reservepossess significant. Accepted manuscript accepted manuscript intermediary asset pricing. Intermediary asset pricing and the financial crisis zhiguohe arvindkrishnamurthy. May 11, 2017 most forms of the capital asset pricing model assume that price differences can be effortlessly arbitraged away. Jan 25, 2016 the price of risk for intermediary capital shocks is consistently positive and of similar magnitude when estimated separately for individual asset classes, suggesting that financial intermediaries are marginal investors in many markets and hence key to understanding asset prices. Presentation at the nber longterm asset management. Soon you can find the first draft here furthermore, i am working on a paper related to intangible capital which is still in progress. Finally, we provide empirical support to the growing literature on intermediary asset pricing e. Ng this dissertation consists of three essays on financial intermediation and asset pricing. Chatterjee the university of wisconsinmilwaukee, 20 under the supervision of dr. We would like to show you a description here but the site wont allow us.
The intermediary asset pricing literature uses two distinct measures of intermediary equity. Wmps are perceived to be as safe as deposits, but with high yields, which. Intermediary asset pricing by zhiguo he and arvind krishnamurthy we model the dynamics of risk premia during crises in asset markets where the marginal investor is a financial intermediary. To describe how leverage risk from shadow banks affects asset prices, we modify the intermediary asset pricing model e.
Book leverage, on the other hand, relies on accounting statement data for both equity and. Inverting the intermediary theory of asset pricing prof. A low price implies a high rate of return, so one can also think of the theory as explaining why some assets pay higher average returns than others. Literature on intermediary asset pricing, the net worth models he and krishnamurthy 20. Intermediary asset pricing stanford graduate school of. We investigate intermediary asset pricing theories empirically and find strong support for intermediary book leverage as the relevant state variable. G01,g12,g21,g24 abstract we find that shocks to the equity capital ratio of financial intermediaries primary dealer counterparties. We model the dynamics of risk premia during crises in asset markets where the marginal investor is a financial intermediary.
Market equity is shares outstanding times stock price. Our paper belongs to a burgeoning literature on intermediary asset pricing, which highlights the pricing kernel of. Hamilton galindo asset pricing corporate finance macro. Poor intermediary health coincides with low asset prices and high risk premia, but it is unclear how much. Intermediary asset pricing at daily frequency policy tensor. Shadow banks, leverage risks, and asset prices sciencedirect. Next we show that the second condition required for intermediaries to. The role of intermediaries in asset pricing chicago. This literature is nascent but quickly growing, especially following the nancial crisis. These theories are predicated on the fact that financial intermediaries are in the advantageous position of trading almost all asset classes, anytime and everywhere.
Exposure to brokerdealer book leverage commands a positive price of risk while high levels of brokerdealer leverage are associated with low future returns. My first book on asset pricing was duffies dynamic asset pricing theory 2nd ed, and it has perhaps forever biased my judgment. New evidence from many asset classes, journal of financial economics, vol. Asset pricing is developed around the concept of a stateprice deflator which relates the price of any asset to its future risky dividends and thus incorporates how to adjust for both time and risk in asset valuation. New evidence from many asset classes zhiguo he university of chicago and nber bryan kelly university of chicago and nber asaf manela washington university in st. I financial intermediary asset pricing an intermediary pricing kernel arises if the balance sheet capacity of intermediaries directly impacts asset price dynamics, as is the case in the literature on limits to arbitrage. Intermediary asset pricing and the swedish equity market jakob barketorp dirke and charles ye may 2016 abstract increasingly, the focus of asset pricing research has shifted from the average household to the more sophisticated financial intermediaries. Intermediary asset pricing and the financial crisis. Rob engles most recent book on empirical asset pricing is good because it has a very thorough treatment of the data. Intermediary asset pricing by zhiguo he and arvind krishnamurthy. May 12, 2017 the role of intermediaries in asset pricing. Some of these models build in a role for intermediaries as well as consumers.
Perhaps motivated by phenomena in the financial crisis, intermediary asset pricing has been one of the fastest growing areas of research in finance. I am working on a new paper which is related to intermediary asset pricing and labor income risk. Asset pricing, corporate finance, economic fluctuations and growth, international finance and macroeconomics. Intermediary based asset pricing intermediary based asset pricing is an active line of research, both theoretical and empirical, which emphasizes the central role of financial intermediaries for asset prices and real outcomes builds on old idea of the financial acceleratorof bernanke and. Aem focus on the security brokerdealer sector and associated book leverage. Section iv analyzes the properties of the lmp and forms portfolios sorted on. The capital asset pricing model capm is a model that describes the relationship between systematic risk and expected return for assets, particularly stocks. In sum, i would try to read or at least skim all of these books.
Financial intermediaries and the crosssection of asset returns. Intermediary asset pricing understands asset prices and risk premia through the lens of frictions in financial intermediation. Acknowledgments this book owes an enormous intellectual debt to lars hansen and gene fama. When the constraint binds, so that intermediaries equity capital is scarce, risk premia rise to reflect the. Book value of debt is equal to total assets less common equity, using the most recent data available for each firm at the end of a calendar quarter. A growing literature on financial intermediaries role in asset pricing has noted the correlations and. Research foundation webcasts and podcasts presentation recorded 09 nov 2018 intermediary asset pricing and the financial crisis arvind krishnamurthy, stanford. Intermediary asset pricing is a branch of heterogeneous agent ap in heterogenous agent models e. The calibrated model matches the nonlinearity of risk premia during. Intermediary asset pricing understands asset prices and risk premia through the. New evidence from many asset classes zhiguo he university of chicago and nber.
Arvind krishnamurthy we present a model to study the dynamics of risk premia during crises in asset markets where the marginal investor is a financial intermediary. Journal of financial economics washington university in. New evidence from many asset classes zhiguo he, bryan kelly, and asaf manela nber working paper no. Our second choice is guided by the recent intermediary asset pricing models ofhe and krishnamurthy20,2012 andbrunnermeier and sannikov2014, which follow the tradition of. We present a model to study the dynamics of risk premia during crises in asset markets where the marginal investor is a financial intermediary. Global variance term premia and intermediary risk appetite, 2017 meeting papers 149, society for economic dynamics. For econometricians, the stochastic discount approach is increasingly important, and. So what is the content of intermediary asset pricing, and does intermediary asset pricing refute traditional consumptionbased asset pricing. Poor intermediary health coincides with low asset prices and high risk premia, but it is unclear how much fluctuations in intermediaries health matter for aggregate asset prices rather than simply being correlated with aggregate risk aversion. Intermediary asset pricing and the financial crisis ebook.
The capital asset pricing model capm is a model that describes the relationship between systematic risk and. His mostcited paper intermediary asset pricing, coauthored with arvind krishnamurthy, presents a model explaining financial crises in markets with complex securities such as mortgagebacked securities and corporate bonds. Intermediary asset pricing and the financial crisis request pdf. Three essays on financial intermediation and asset pricing. Our papers dif fer in the definition of financial intermediaries and in data sources. This paper assesses the extent to which intermediary capital ic risk contributes toward explaining commodity futures returns. Intermediary asset pricing american economic association. Intermediary s pricing kernel and capital ratio i pricing kernel is marginal value of wealth formarginal investors.
Intermediaries face a constraint on raising equity. Fluctuations in the riskbearing capacity of brokerdealers drive fluctuations in asset prices. Risk premia rise when the constraint binds, reflecting the capital scarcity. Intermediarysic code 6 finance, insurance, real estate. Intermediary asset pricing becker friedman institute university of. Intermediarybased asset pricing and the crosssections of. There is a problem of timescale in intermediary asset pricing.
Asset pricing theory tries to understand the prices or values of claims to uncertain payments. Dynamic leverage asset pricing by tobias adrian, emanuel. Intermediary asset pricing zhiguo he arvind krishnamurthy. Technical material is updated with each new edition and this book is correct as at 15 september 2012. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. Intermediaries face a constraint on raising equity capital. Financial intermediaries and the crosssection of asset. The calibrated model matches the nonlinearity of risk premia during crises.
These terms are all familiar from the textbook treatment of portfolio choice in. The editor of the journal of financial economics highlighted article from the latest published issue of the journal intermediary asset pricing. The price of risk for intermediary capital shocks is consistently positive and of similar magnitude when estimated separately for individual asset classes, suggesting that financial intermediaries are marginal investors in many markets and hence key to understanding asset prices. Intermediary asset pricing zhiguo he arvind krishnamurthy november 20, 2008 abstract we study the dynamics of risk premia during crises where nancial intermediaries faces constraints on raising equity capital.
New evidence from many asset classes i zhiguo he a, bryan kelly a, asaf manela b a university of chicago, booth school of business, and nber, 5807 s woodlawn ave, chicago, il 60637, usa b washington university, olin business school, one brookings dr, st. Financial intermediaries and the crosssection of asset returns 2561 section ii describes the data and empirical strategy, and section iii conducts a number of asset pricing tests in the crosssection of stock and bond returns. Do intermediaries matter for aggregate asset prices. First, this paper most naturally relates to the literature on intermediary asset pricing. Intermediary asset pricing and the swedish equity market. In such frameworks, the leverage of nancial intermediaries measures the tightness of intermediary funding constraints and. G01,g12,g21,g24 abstract we find that shocks to the equity capital ratio of financial intermediariesprimary dealer counterparties. Financial asset pricing theory offers a comprehensive overview of the classic and the current research in theoretical asset pricing. When the constraint binds, so that intermediaries equity capital is scarce, risk premia rise to reflect the capital scarcity. Intermediary asset pricing, 2010 meeting papers 27, society for economic dynamics.
Louis, mo 63, usa abstract we nd that shocks to the equity. Intermediary asset pricing zhiguo he, arvind krishnamurthy. Three essays on financial intermediation and asset pricing by ujjal k. We empirically investigate the predictions from alternative intermediary asset pricing theories. The rest is elaboration, special cases, and a closet full of tricks that make the central equation useful for one or. Virtually all intermediary asset pricing theories would suggest using market values, which reflect forwardlooking information available in traded securities prices. While we have data on dealer balance sheets on a quarterly basis, dealers care more about daytoday or even intraday fluctuations. New evidence from many asset classes zhiguo he, bryan kelly, asaf manela.
February 27, 2012 abstract we model the dynamics of risk premia during crises in asset markets where the marginal investor is a. Mar 14, 2019 in the last few years, the intermediary theory of asset pricing has emerged as a single factor model of asset pricing that does as well as the standard four factor model and thus subsumes the size, value and momentum factors adrian, t. Risk premia rise when intermediariesequity capital is scarce. We find that the ic effect is substantially positive and continues to grow as the financialization of commodities deepens. Intermediary asset pricing and the financial crisis annual. Intermediary asset pricing in commodity futures returns. But any asset holder not at a corner in his or her portfolio choice is marginal. Intermediary asset pricing simon fraser university. Intermediary asset pricing and the financial crisis, nber working papers 24415, national bureau of economic research, inc. Dec 01, 2019 there is a problem of timescale in intermediary asset pricing.
We find that shocks to the equity capital ratio of financial intermediaries primary dealer. Intermediary asset pricing theories offer a new perspective for understanding risk premia. Perhaps motivated by phenomena in the financial crisis, intermediary. Perhaps motivated by phenomena in the financial crisis, intermediary asset pricing has been one of the fastestgrowing areas of research in finance. Intermediary managers wealth constrains size of intermediary s overall equity, for moral hazard reasons. Newer asset pricing models allow for limits to arbitrage, such as an inability to borrow or lend large amounts of money at the riskfree rate.
Intermediary asset pricing, nber working papers 14517, national bureau of economic research, inc. New evidence from many asset classes i zhiguo he a, bryan kelly a, asaf manela b a university of chicago, booth school of business, and nber, 5807 s woodlawn ave, chicago, il 60637, usa. Newer asset pricing models allow for limits to arbitrage, such as an inability to borrow or lend large amounts of. Its probably true that the first book you study about a subject inevitably determines your approach to it afterwards.
1184 1034 898 31 1192 1346 1272 1207 947 951 1258 939 1108 282 1472 1027 1226 328 1367 1280 445 583 1376 1279 721 92 213 324 600 1169 1476 1027 339 1127 843 123 686 238 547 800